BullionBase

Commitment

BullionBase Open Data Pledge

A plain-language, public, dated commitment. Every change is itself dated and recorded in the changelog. Nothing here can be quietly weakened.

Why this exists

BullionBase is built entirely from the knowledge, time, and care of its contributors - collectors, researchers, dealers, and enthusiasts.

Whether a community database succeeds comes down to one thing: whether the people who build it trust that their work stays theirs and stays open. This page is that commitment, stated plainly and permanently, so you never have to take it on faith.

What is open, and how it is licensed

Two separate licenses, because data and images are legally different things:

The structured database (producers, items, editions, specifications, mintages, edit history)

ODbL v1.0

the OpenStreetMap license. Open forever, share-alike, attribution required.

Contributor-submitted text and uploaded images

CC BY-SA 4.0

free to reuse, including commercially, with attribution and share-alike. Deliberately not a non-commercial license, so reuse by anyone is genuinely unrestricted.

What is not in it. The open dataset is the catalog: what these objects are. Commercial information about who is selling them, at what price, and in what quantity is not part of it, is not ours to give away, and is never included in the monthly release. That boundary is about authorship, not convenience: everything the community contributes to the catalog is in the release, permanently. Nor does the release say anything about the people who contribute: it records every edit, but not who made it, because people who photograph bullion are photographing what they hold.

Your contribution stays yours

When you contribute, you keep ownership of your work. You grant BullionBase a perpetual, irrevocable license to publish it under the open licenses above (ODbL for the structured data, CC BY-SA 4.0 for text and images), and in return BullionBase commits to keeping it under those open licenses permanently. The full Contributor License Agreement is section 5 of the Terms of Use; the above is its plain-language essence.

The promise that makes every other promise real

Every month, BullionBase publishes the entire structured database as an open download, under ODbL, in stable documented per-entity formats (the way OpenStreetMap does it, not a fragile internal dump), validated to stand on its own.

Anyone - a competitor, a researcher, or any contributor - can take the complete dataset at any time and walk away with it. We never hold the only copy, and the license means we never can.

That protection does not depend on our goodwill, our funding, our owners, or our survival. If BullionBase were sold, abandoned, or shut down tomorrow, the data is already in the world, openly licensed, irrevocably. The project can outlive the company. That is the entire point.

What we may do commercially, and why it cannot harm you

BullionBase has no advertising, no paid tiers, and no marketplace today. We may never have any of them.

We are also not promising to stay free of them, because a promise we might one day be forced to break would be worth nothing to you, and a hidden plan would be worse. So, plainly: in future BullionBase may offer commercial services - for example advertising, paid API access, or a marketplace - built as services on top of the open data. ODbL expressly allows this; it calls them “Produced Works”, and they are how an open project funds staying open.

Here is why that cannot cost you anything. The data underneath stays ODbL, the monthly open release never stops, and you can always take the entire dataset and leave. We can only ever build on top of something we have already given away irrevocably. We never control the exit, so we can never hold the community’s work hostage to a business model.

Specific commitments

  1. 1The data is never sold exclusively. No commercial arrangement, however valuable, will ever give any party exclusive access to or control of the community’s data. It is open to everyone under ODbL, including our own competitors.
  2. 2Rankings are never for sale. Search results, browse order, and navigation always reflect data quality and community signals - accuracy, completeness, votes - never who paid. Advertising, if it ever exists, is always clearly labeled and never influences data or rankings.
  3. 3Contributor history is preserved. Your edits, points, and reputation are the record of your work, and we do not delete or suppress them. Every edit is part of the open release, but who made it is not: the release carries no contributor identifier of any kind. On the site you choose how you are credited - your handle, or “a BullionBase contributor” - and you can change your mind at any time without breaking the record.
  4. 4BullionBase is not sold to a dealer or competitor. It will not be sold to a mint, refinery, dealer, or any party whose commercial interest conflicts with the neutrality of the database. An independent reference is the whole value; we will not turn it into anyone’s marketing tool.

Open data, not open code

This pledge is about the data, not the software. The BullionBase platform’s source code is private and is expected to stay private. ODbL obligates us to keep the data open; it does not require us to publish our code, and we do not. An open dataset on a closed platform is a deliberate choice. Open data is a promise we can keep absolutely; promising open source would be a different and far larger commitment we are not making, and blurring the two would make this pledge less honest, not more.

Stewardship over time

The binding force of everything above is the ODbL license and the monthly open release. Both are legally irrevocable and depend on no particular company or structure - which is exactly why they are the foundation rather than a promise of good behavior.

As BullionBase grows, we intend to move stewardship of the open data and the BullionBase name into an independent non-profit foundation, the way OpenStreetMap and Wikipedia are stewarded. We state it as a direction we are committed to, not a dated deadline, so the commitment is real rather than performative. The protections above are in force from day one and do not wait on it.

Changelog

Every change to this pledge is recorded here with its date. Protections are only ever added or strengthened, never quietly weakened.

2026-11-14 - Published. The pledge takes effect as BullionBase opens to readers.